Home / History & Education

Was Paul the Founder of Christianity? The Case, Weighed

· · Updated

Was Paul the founder of Christianity? Diagram of a network of early house churches linked by Paul's letters.

In 60 seconds

Paul did not invent faith in Jesus: his own letters show believers worshipping the risen Jesus before he joined them. But he shaped Christianity more than anyone except Jesus, opening it to non-Jews, writing its earliest texts and building its church network. Scholars still debate whether that makes him a founder.

Key points

  1. Thirteen of the New Testament's 27 books carry Paul's name (seven are undisputed), and the Acts of the Apostles is largely about him.
  2. The "Paul as founder" thesis goes back to the Tübingen school of the 1800s; modern defenders include Gerd Lüdemann and Hyam Maccoby.
  3. Against it: Paul persecuted Christians before joining them and quotes a creed he received from earlier believers (1 Corinthians 15:3–7).
  4. Paul's decisive move was opening the movement to non-Jews without circumcision, settled after a clash with James and Peter.
  5. Professor Jiang argues Paul turned Jesus's teaching of an inner divine spark into an obedient, household-based church sold to slave-owners.

CAUTION

Independent analysis of Professor Jiang Xueqin's public lecture (Secret History #23). Not affiliated with Professor Jiang. Quotes are short and linked to the source; analysis is ours. We discuss history, not anyone's faith.

Was Paul the founder of Christianity? Not in the sense of inventing it: his own letters show that people were already worshipping the risen Jesus before Paul joined them. But Paul did more than anyone else to turn a Jewish movement into a religion for the whole Roman world. He wrote its earliest surviving texts, defined faith in Christ as the path to salvation, opened it to non-Jews and built a network of churches across the empire. Whether that makes him a "founder" depends on what you think Jesus started.

The case for Paul as founder

The argument is old. In the 1800s the German scholar Ferdinand Christian Baur and the Tübingen school saw early Christianity as a conflict between a Jewish party around Peter and James and a universal party around Paul, which won. In the twentieth century Hyam Maccoby (The Mythmaker, 1986) and Gerd Lüdemann (Paul: The Founder of Christianity, 2002) pushed it further.

Their evidence is strong on its face. Thirteen of the New Testament's 27 books carry Paul's name, seven of them accepted by nearly all scholars as his. His letters, from about 50 to 60 CE, are older than any gospel. Jesus, in the first three gospels, preaches the coming Kingdom of God to Jews; Paul preaches Jesus himself, crucified and risen, to everyone. And Paul rarely quotes Jesus's teaching.

The case against

The strongest objection comes from Paul. He admits he "persecuted the church of God" before joining it (Galatians 1:13), so the movement, and its devotion to Jesus, existed without him. He passes on a creed he "received" from earlier believers: Christ died for our sins, was buried, was raised, appeared to Peter and to James (1 Corinthians 15:3–7). Larry Hurtado (Lord Jesus Christ, 2003) showed how early that devotion was. Bart Ehrman and N. T. Wright, from very different positions, both reject the founder label.

Paul also quotes Jesus more than critics allow: the Last Supper words (1 Corinthians 11:23–25), the ban on divorce (7:10). And his signature phrase "circumcision of the heart" comes from Deuteronomy and Jeremiah, not from Greek philosophy.

Some of the ideas Paul built on, the resurrection of the dead and a final judgment, are older still: many historians trace them to Persian contact after 539 BC; see was Zoroastrianism the first monotheistic religion?

Paul and the first Christians
  1. c. 30–33 CE

    Crucifixion of Jesus

    Followers report resurrection appearances

  2. c. 33–36 CE

    Paul's conversion

    After persecuting the movement

  3. c. 48–49 CE

    Jerusalem meeting

    Non-Jewish converts need not be circumcised

  4. c. 50 CE

    1 Thessalonians

    Earliest surviving Christian text

  5. c. 57 CE

    Letter to the Romans

    Faith in Christ, Jew and Gentile alike

  6. c. 62–64 CE

    James killed; Paul dies in Rome

    Traditional dating of Paul's execution under Nero

  7. c. 70–100 CE

    Gospels written

    After Paul's letters

What Paul actually changed

If Paul did not invent faith in Jesus, he did decide who could share it. The first followers were Jews who kept the Law. Paul insisted that non-Jews could join without circumcision or the food laws, and after a sharp clash with Peter and James (Galatians 2; Acts 15) his view prevailed. That one decision made Christianity a world religion instead of a Jewish sect. He also gave it a theology for that world: Jew and Greek, slave and free, saved by faith rather than by the Law (Romans 3; Galatians 3:28).

Christianity took about three centuries to reach roughly 6 million believers. Six centuries after Paul, Arab armies took Syria, Egypt and Persia in about 20 years, though conversion there was far slower; we compare the two in why did Islam spread so fast?

What Professor Jiang says about Paul

In Secret History #23, Jiang takes the founder thesis further than most scholars. "Christianity is a religion about Jesus, but not by Jesus. It's by Paul" (16:26). In his reading, Jesus taught that a divine spark lives in each person; Paul pulled "the greatest trick ever" by moving faith from Jesus's words to his person: believe in Jesus and you'll be saved (05:21).

His most original point is structural. Paul, he argues, modeled the church on the Roman household, the paterfamilias system of a patriarch, his sons, his slaves and his freed clients, which made it easy for masters to convert with their whole households. "Jesus was talking to slaves but Paul was talking to patriarchs" (13:51). He compares Paul to Ray Kroc, who built McDonald's by selling franchises rather than burgers: "Jesus is a prophet, but Paul is a business person" (19:13).

Jiang makes a similar argument about a far older religion: Babylon's creation epic, which he reads as making toil and hierarchy look divinely ordained. See the Enuma Elish explained.

What the record shows

The household part of Jiang's argument has real support. Wayne Meeks's The First Urban Christians (1983) found that Paul's churches met in the homes of better-off patrons and mixed slaves with householders, and Acts describes whole households baptized together. Rodney Stark estimated steady growth of about 40% per decade, from roughly 1,000 believers in 40 CE to about 6 million by 300, the kind of growth that household conversion makes plausible.

Bar chart of Rodney Stark's estimate of early Christian growth: 1,000 believers in 40 CE to about 6.3 million by 300 CE at 40% per decade.

Other parts need correcting. Paul was no wealthy executive: he worked as a tentmaker and thanked congregations for gifts. He named women as church leaders, including Phoebe and Junia (Romans 16). And the idea that Paul was a Roman agent appears in no ancient source. The fairest verdict is the one many historians reach: Jesus started a movement; Paul, more than anyone, decided what it would become.

Who wrote scripture, and why, is a question that goes back to the Bible's first pages; we weigh the theory that the oldest layer of Genesis was written by a woman in was Genesis written by a woman?

More on Jiang's history lectures: Universe 25 and elite overproduction and who invented kindergarten. For his forecasts, see Professor Jiang's latest predictions.

Our guide to his Secret History series, How Power Works, is out. Read the first chapter free. New analyses also go out on Telegram.

Prefer video? Weekly 20-minute lecture cuts + fact-checks in our Inner Circle (founding price $5/month).

Jiang This Week, free every Sunday

One email: what Professor Jiang said this week, which predictions came due, and what the evidence shows. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

Frequently asked questions

Why do some people say Paul founded Christianity?

Because Paul wrote the earliest Christian texts, shaped its central doctrine (salvation through faith in Christ), opened it to non-Jews and built its network of churches. Jesus, by contrast, preached the Kingdom of God to fellow Jews and left no writings.

Did Paul ever meet Jesus?

Not during Jesus's lifetime, as far as we know. Paul says the risen Jesus appeared to him (1 Corinthians 15:8); Acts describes this as a light on the road to Damascus. He later met Peter and James, Jesus's brother, in Jerusalem (Galatians 1:18–19).

Does Paul quote Jesus?

Rarely, but he does: the words at the Last Supper (1 Corinthians 11:23–25), the ban on divorce (7:10) and the rule that preachers should live by the gospel (9:14). Scholars debate whether his readers already knew the teachings.

What does Professor Jiang say about Paul?

Jiang calls Christianity "a religion about Jesus, but not by Jesus. It's by Paul." He argues Paul moved faith from Jesus's words to his person and modeled the church on the Roman household, selling it to patriarchs rather than slaves.

Related analysis